Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you hit links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Sharp wings, right this way.
Byrdie
A stellar budget-friendly pick is thee.l.f.
Waterproof eyeliners are great, in theory.
After all, who doesnt want their precision-applied lined look to last as long as possible?
PHOTO: Stila
This is why waterproof eyeliners regularly get a bad rap.
As you might have guessed, some fared better than others.
Here are the ones that stood up to the sweat and tears.
We loved how pigmented it was compared to others tested.
Best Crayon
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG!
Once on, it feels weightless, making it a particularly comfortable liner option.
PHOTO: Ulta
We loved that this liner truly doesnt budge when mixed with sweat or splashed with water.
Still, its workable enough to touch up withmicellar waterto create even sharper lines.
Fresh out of the shower, there wasnt a trace of the liner left behind.
PHOTO: Byrdie
Best Budget
e.l.f.
Eyeliner Pen is proofit costs under $10 and outperforms many of the other liners tested.
Its not perfect, though; it is somewhat difficult to remove.
It glides on beautifully and dries down quickly, making the utility process much more seamless.
Still, its easy to layer, and doing so doesnt result in a caked-on finish.
It also comes off easilyand entirelywith acleansing balm, a major plus.
With Fenty Beautys Flyliner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner, you’re free to do just that.
Still, its easy to remove when acleanseris introduced.
Nevertheless, this remains a comfortable, long-lasting option worth trying.
The inky formula is highly pigmented and dries almost immediately.
Once dry, it wont budge from sweat or blinking.
So while you have to move fast, we think the exceptional wear is worth the effort.
This pick comes in an impressive 34 different shades, including matte and glitter finishes.
Luckily, a couple of layers and a touchup with micellar water can easily address both concerns.
They paid special attention to ease of software, longevity, wearability, and overall look.
Anytime you get anything in your eye, you should promptly flush it out with water.
Simply dip a cotton swab into micellar water and swipe it across the liner error.
Whatever cleanser you choose, ensure its safe for your eyes.
PHOTO: Ulta
Caitlyn Martynis an associate editor at Byrdie, where she covers beauty and style-related topics.
She is an experienced product tester and relies on staff and tester insights to inform this story.
To guide her recommendations, she considered each product’s formulation and intended purpose.
PHOTO: Byrdie
PHOTO: Sephora
PHOTO: Fenty Beauty
PHOTO: Byrdie
PHOTO: Sephora
Byrdie
PHOTO: Amazon
PHOTO: Byrdie
PHOTO: Sephora
PHOTO: Amazon
Byrdie
Byrdie
