Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.

If you tap on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

And they’re great for hooded eyes, too.

Before and after of a person holding a liquid eyeliner pen with a swipe on their hand, and after applying liquid eyeliner

Byrdie

No one likes to admit theyre picky, but I can be a stickler aboutliquid eyeliner.

So, I was genuinely surprised to fall in love with not one butnineout of the 16 differenteyelinersItested.

Drugstore heroes,waterproof formulas, and pens worth the splurge were all in the running.

L’Oreal Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

PHOTO: Ulta

Ultimately, the nine in the list below are worthy of a place in yourmakeup bag.

you’re able to also find it at the closestdrugstore.

I cant say enough good things about it.

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using L’Oreal Paris Flash Cat Eye Eyeliner

Check, check, and check.

Ive got no complaints about this formula.

It set after about two minutes and didn’t transfer at all when I put my finger on it.

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

PHOTO: Target

The pigment is awesome; its inky right out of the gate and offers really nice coverage.

In Anastasias waterproof formula, I found just that.

I didnt end up needing to touch up the liner at all.

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using NYX epic ink liner

This liner glides on beautifully and achieves a really inky wing in just a few seconds.

I can easily draw the exact shape with its long tip and easy-to-hold pen.

That said, Ilias liquid liner exceeded my expectations.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Liner

PHOTO: Amazon

While it wasnt the inkiest of the bunch, the liquidapplied easilywith minimal tugging thanks to its easy-to-glide tip.

The formulas longevity impressed me, too.

The liquid glided on smoothly in one bold stroke without skipping.

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using Anastasia Beverly Hills Waterproof Matte Liquid Eyeliner

It took about 30 seconds to set, and once it did, it didnt budge.

Despite its many merits, I do wish this formula was slightly more inky in tone.

Beyond the applicator, the formula itself is just as impressive.

Benefit Cosmetics Roller Liner Matte Liquid Eyeliner in Brown

PHOTO: Walmart

This liner stayed on really well throughout the daydespite the humidity.

There was no flakiness at all, and the color remained bold well into the night.

I loved how comfy this liquid felt on my lids.

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using Benefit cosmetic roller liner

As it dried down in a thin layer (a good thing!

), it didnt feel heavy at all.

This liner was an exception.

Ilia Clean Line Liquid Eyeliner

PHOTO: Sephora

It was comfy the whole day I wore it and only required a touch-up or two.

Use your other hand to gently pull your eye taut (no tugging!)

and apply small dots or dashes as close to the lash line as possible.

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using Ilia Clean Line Liquid Eyeliner

Some liquid eyeliners last longer than others; it is what it is.

The number one tip pros agree on is simple.

Also, verify you store your liner tip down to help the product flow more smoothly.

Ulta MAC Brushstroke Eyeliner

PHOTO: Ulta

A good liquid eyeliner should last you three to six months, depending on how often you use it.

Removing your liquid eyeliner is as easy as a few swipes ofmicellar wateroreye makeup remover.

She holds a Masters degree in English and Creative Writing from Monmouth University.

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using MAC brushstroke 24 hour liner

Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner

PHOTO: Walmart

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using Maybelline hyper easy brush tip liquid liner

NARS Climax Liquid Eyeliner

PHOTO: Amazon

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using Nars Climax Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

One/Size by Patrick Starrr Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen

PHOTO: Sephora

Site Loop: Person’s eye before and after using One/size point made waterproof liquid liner