Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you hit links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Never buy and return leggings again with this definitive list.
Byrdie / Caitlin Martyn / Cher Checchio / Lauren Pardee
We have alsoseen firsthandhow investing in qualityleggingsmotivates us to workout more.
Here are the best black leggings that make us never want to wear jeans again.
While some leggings are meant just for working out and others for relaxing, the Aligns serve both purposes.
PHOTO: lululemon
If we could only buy and wear one pair of leggings, it would be these.
Shannon Bauer, associate editorial director:I have bought many cheaper dupes and lululemon wins every time.
The softness of the fabric, fit, and longevity make the investment worthwhile.
We are impressed with how well the brushed nylon fabric keeps us cool while walking around in 70-degree weather.
They are a great choice for the gym, thanks to the sweat-wicking, squat-proof fabric.
They also do a wonderful job at making your butt look good.
PHOTO: Amazon
As also hinted in the name, the curved waistband helps to emphasize your backside in a subtle way.
We ordered the short length and were pleased with how well they fit our 53 frame.
They hit us at the perfect spot above our ankles and slightly above our belly button.
Caitlyn Martyn, associate editor:I love the high-waisted cross-over waistline that flatters my midsection.
The thick waistband compresses and smooths the stomach yet still is comfortable.
The rest of the legging is thin and lightweight and offers a cooling sensation on the skin.
PHOTO: Old Navy
Its durable too, with no piling or loose threads post-wash.
If you dont like front seams, Gymshark is known for offeringseamless leggingsthat dont sag.
They passed all the exercise tests and didn’t weigh me down, ride up, or show sweat.
The fabric is thick, opaque, and has held up well for years.
Though they come in one inseam, they fit our 51 tester perfectly.
They also dont pick up lint as easily as the Aligns, which is great news for pet owners.
PHOTO: Aritzia
And after all these years, they still look great and remain squat-proof.
Shannon Bauer, associate editorial director:I love how comfortable these are.
It’s my go-to for rot days on the couch, walks, and long-haul flights.
The pockets are a great addition for travel where you want to keep your phone handy.
In fact, the Spacedye fabric may be one of the softest fabrics weve felt in leggings.
Despite its thick texture, it still keeps us cool and dry in warm weather and heated workouts.
PHOTO: Aerie
The fabric features a marbled design, which camouflages any cellulite in the back of your thighs.
Beyond black, they come in a range of vibrant colors and up to size 4X.
Ally Hirschlag, associate editorial director:The material is among the softest leggings material I’ve experienced.
It’s so smooth, substantial, yet lightweight.
I’m as comfortable wearing them in 80-degree weather as I am in the dead of winter.
Besides looking cute, this feature helps you snatch your waist and prevent the leggings from rolling down.
PHOTO: Gymshark
Dominique Hobdy, senior editor:I love love love the material of these.
They’re a blend of nylon and spandex so they’re super stretchy and give great coverage.
We regret to inform your wallet that we do think the Alosoft leggings are worth the hype.
Four-way stretch allows you to do all the downward dogs while staying dry.
When it comes to flare designs, Split59 does it best with its Raquel Split Him.
The material is nice and thick, sculpting our curves and resisting any wear or tear.
PHOTO: Set
I personally like how the material is thicker than the Aerie flare leggings.
Fashion industry expert and content creatorSara Walkerhas a few favorite formulas for styling leggings beyond the gym.
I love theoversized graphic tee, leggings,headband, and sneakers for the sporty look, says Walker.
Leggings,tank top, blazer,riding bootsthis gives off the effortlessly cool tailored look while wearing leggings.
Perfect for a travel day!"
She has tried hundreds of leggings over the years and participated in this Byrdie test.
PHOTO: Athleta
PHOTO: Amazon
PHOTO: Years of Ours
PHOTO: Alo
PHOTO: Split59
Byrdie/Jhett Thompson
