Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you choose links we provide, we may receive compensation.
No more mascara residue?
Byrdie
Its no-rinse, cleansing, and nourishing formula makes it the number one pick.The E.l.f.
Weve all been here before.
Theres nothing worse than an eye makeup remover that fails to get the job done quickly and painlessly.
PHOTO: Target
Ahead, find my favorite irritation-free eye makeup removers that truly sped up the process.
Its gentle yet powerful formula cleanses the skin without stripping it of moisture and swiftlyremoves eye makeup.
It did not irritate mysensitive skinbut felt cooling and soothing, which I appreciated.
I used this on a day when my cheeks and nose were slightlysunburnt, and it did not sting.
Thismicellar waterhas unconventional uses, too, further expanding its value.
Plus, its only $12 for 13.5 ounces, which should last me a while.
PHOTO: Amazon
And for $11, it rivals most of the high-end cleansing balms I’ve tried.
It was perfect at removing everything on nights when I had a full face of glam.
I was left looking a bit like a raccoon, but in the best way possible.
It certainly lives up to its name because it feels hydratinglike a drink of water for your face.
This is thanks tohyaluronic acid, which is known for it’s nourishing and soothing properties.
It left my skin feelingplump, smooth, and nourished.
PHOTO: Sephora
Its a no-brainer for affordable hydration and makeup-melting power.
Within a few swipes of this product, my eyeshadow, eyeliner, and mascara were gone.
It felt gentle on my skin, and I didn’t notice any signs of irritation while testing.
The best part: it doesnt need to be rinsed off.
My skin felt cleansed and moisturized, all thanks to the multitasking power and the one-and-done process.
I think the hefty price tag is worth it for the speedy results.
PHOTO: Nordstrom
The formula was incredibly gentle, did not irritate my skin, and was contact lens-approved.
Its similar to the Lancome remover with its double-action, biphase formula, but its not as greasy.
Its also not quite as speedy as its Lancome counterpart, and takes slightly more effort for total removal.
As someone who wearscontacts, I appreciate that it doesnt cloud or sting my eyes.
The brand mentions it can be used for face makeup, too; it removed myfoundationandpowderproducts exceptionally well.
Formulated withclean ingredientsand plant-based cloth, theyre good for the planet and your skin.
PHOTO: La Roche-Posay
I used a second wipe for the remaining mascara on my lashes, which did the trick.
With a thick consistency close toVaseline, this product felt soothing on the skin.
The dual-action formula cleanses and moisturizes the skin (it’s a makeup remover and a true cleanser).
The luxe oils quite literally melted my makeup off, thus living up to its name.
I was astonished when my mascara instantly dissolved, and no residue was left on my lashes.
The one con for me was the packaging.
PHOTO: Sephora
I had to use one cotton round for each eye to get totally clean lids and lashes.
It did feel slightly greasy on my lids, even though it claims to leave no oily residue.
This cleansing oil felt luxurious upon utility, and the lavender scent was soothing.
It turned creamy when met with water and immediately started to break down my face and eye makeup.
The result was a clean lash and eyelid, free from any residue.
However, it never left a greasy feeling after use, just a hydrated and nourished complexion.
PHOTO: Amazon
A moisturizing formula made with Japanese indigo extract, it is calming and nourishing for dry skin types.
It even comes with a convenient gold coin that makes scooping up the product effortless and hygienic.
I instantly noticed that it wasfragrance-free, which is a plus for my sensitive skin.
The consistency is very thick, but it instantly absorbs into the skin once applied, breaking down makeup.
My eyeshadow and eyeliner dissolved, and my mascara quickly followed.
However, once it did, the result was a clean, moisturized, and soft face.
PHOTO: Sephora
I recommend keeping the following factors in mind to determine which eye makeup remover is right for you.
Harsh rubbing in the eye area can cause irritation and damage to your lashes and delicate skin.
Instead of using a textured washcloth, opt for a soft cotton pad or cloth with a smooth texture.
My tip for removing glitter is to start with a wipe, Smith says.
I wrap it around my finger and roll to remove the glitter.
If you swipe back and forth, glitter will transfer all over your face.
PHOTO: Amazon
Any leftover specks are easily removed with clear tape.
Just tap that over the area, and it instantly lifts the glitter off!
It may also leave the face feeling greasy.
Ercan Z. E. (2022).
Effect of eyeliner and mascara use on tear film and meibomian glands.
PHOTO: Sephora
PHOTO: Tatcha
Byrdie
