Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you hit links we provide, we may receive compensation.
They rival high-end favorites, and prices start as low as $5.
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
Lash Xtndr Tubing Mascarathe results and performance seriously rival high-end options.
Im saying it: If theres one makeup item thedrugstoredoes best, itsmascara.
Theyre so plentiful that choosing one to suit your preferences may make your head spin.
PHOTO: Amazon
The products included on this list have all made the tough cut.
I can wear it on minimal makeup days or build it up to suit moredramaticlooks.
Perhaps the best part is that it doesnt flake or smudgeeven on the most humid days.
PHOTO: Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
One coat gave me noticeable length and thickness, while a second coat created more drama.
Best Tubing
e.l.f.
This one truly meets higher-end options.
After testing it for several months, I can confirm that I never experienced flaking or smudgingnot one time.
Its buildable without getting too clumpy.
Best Curling
e.l.f.
Lash N' Roll.
While I do have relatively curled lashes to begin with, I noticed that this mascara accentuated their curve.
The half-moon-shaped brush hugs your eyes, gripping each lash from the root and coating it in the formula.
I didnt experience smudging or flaking and the removal process was painless.
I never experience clumping or weighed-down lashes when I wear this oneIm always left with clean-looking definition that lasts.
While it added serious volume, this formula never weighed down my lashes or depleted their curl.
PHOTO: Ulta
I was able to achieve a wide-awake look that lasted all day.
This one from L’Oreal does just that.
With one coat, my lashes looked dark and naturally defined.
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
But with two and then three coats, I got significant volume and noticeable length.
The formula didnt weigh down my lashes or create significant smudgingit lasted well throughout the day.
It does look noticeably brown on my lashes, and the formula is fantastic.
PHOTO: e.l.f.
It nicely defined my lashes, giving them moderate length and volume thats perfect for minimal makeup days.
This is the brown mascara you want for a natural lookandtop-tier performance.
The utility process was fast and easy, and the look it created was among my favorites.
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
Things got tricky with its performance.
On one of the days I tested it, I only experienced minimal smudging.
Admittedly, I think the name of this mascara is a bit misleading.
PHOTO: Ulta
I think its best for those who want to achieve subtle, fluffy-looking lashes.
It wore nicely throughout the day without smudging, bleeding, or flaking.
When applying each mascara, I took note of how many coats it took to achieve my desired look.
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
Does it last all day without smudging, bleeding, or flaking?
), wear well without flaking or smudging, and arent a pain to remove.
She has been at Byrdie since 2022, where she covers all things beauty.
PHOTO: e.l.f.
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
PHOTO: Ulta
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
PHOTO: Amazon
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
PHOTO: Ulta
PHOTO: Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
PHOTO: Amazon
Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
PHOTO: Ulta
PHOTO: Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
PHOTO: Ulta
PHOTO: Byrdie / Alyssa Kaplan
Byrdie/Alexander Huang
