Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you choose links we provide, we may receive compensation.
No budging, no smudging.
Byrdie / Kevin Liang
This applies to both extensions and more temporaryfalse lashesoil breaks down the adhesive.
What We Don’t Like:Must be sharpened frequently.
We also like how it comes with a brush on the other end.
PHOTO: Sephora
What We Don’t Like:Challenging to sharpen.
Fans ofsoft glam makeupwill love the slightly metallic finish to some of the shades.
This liner is the perfect option to accompany a dewy base and light smokey eye.
Byrdie / Clare Holden
What We Don’t Like:Only comes in two colors.
oz |Cruelty-Free:Yes
This gentle formula was one of the most durable liners we tested.
The semi-matte finish isfragrance-free with the added benefit of being infused with vitamin E andchamomile.
PHOTO: Ulta
What We Don’t Like:Limited color options.
What We Don’t Like:Compact sold separately from pan.
|Cruelty-Free:Yes
If youre someone who likes totightline, this formula is for you.
PHOTO: Amazon
If you want to create a subtler line, use a drier brushit wont pick up as much color.
What We Don’t Like:Difficult to remove.
Its a must for those who love an intense liner look.
PHOTO: Nordstrom
The only downside is that its staying power means it’s hard to remove.
What We Don’t Like:Can dry out quickly.
Format:Liquid |Shades:15 |Size:.01 oz.
PHOTO: MOB Beauty
|Cruelty-Free:No
Thomas recommends this formula for its durability (24 hours of wear!)
Plus it comes in 15 different colors.
What We Don’t Like:Brush could be improved.
PHOTO: Pat McGrath
It has a unique extended tip for precision tool over lashes and unique eye shapes.
It can even be applied overmagnetic lashes.
The pigment and finishes are fantastic, just be sure to be extra careful when sharpening.
Byrdie / Clare Holden
This product provides both the durability of a pencil but with the sleek finish of a liquid liner.
What We Don’t Like:Soft crayon breaks easily.
|Cruelty-Free:Yes
This automatic liner has long been a mainstay of those with sensitive eyes on a budget.
PHOTO: Sephora
The long-lasting and water-resistant formula is ophthalmologist tested and infused with vitamin E for comfortable wear.
and the available shades flatter all eye colors.
The formula stays in place and lasts for hours while the self-sharpener means its always ready to use.
Byrdie / Clare Holden
How youtake offyour oil-free eyeliner will depend on how stubborn the formula is.
Thomas recommends usingmicellar wateron a cotton round or gauze, then following up with a moistened cotton swab.
She converted to oil-free formulas years ago due to just how much longer they last.
PHOTO: Melt Cosmetics
Byrdie / Jessica Juliao
PHOTO: Ulta
Byrdie / Clare Holden
PHOTO: Amazon
