If you choose links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Emily McDonagh

We put five skincare slugging methods to the test after receiving complimentary samples from select brands.

Keep reading for a thorough comparison.

Byrdie writer Emily McDonagh holds the Futurewise Slugging System products

Emily McDonagh

If I were a skincare product, I’d be a lipid-loadedmoisturizer.

Applying a good cream or balm is like calling a friend to debrief or relaxing at home without shoes.

Born from K-beauty wisdom,slugginghas taken over TikTok and our skincare routines.

Futurewise Slug Balm pink jar in hand

Emily McDonagh

What Is Slugging?

“Sluggingis the process of applying a physical barrier to the skin.

Slugging can be a dream for thirsty skin.

Byrdie writer Emily McDonagh’s skin after applying the Futurewise Slugging System

Emily McDonagh

“It’s also a great option for those who travel often.

About My Skin

As a cold-weather-averse traveler with dry skin, slugging has helped my skin immensely.

After one or two retinol snafus, slugging helped repair mybarrier.

Futurewise Slugging System: mist, cream, and balm

It’s the silent meditation retreat of skincare rituals, but at the cost of my silk pillowcase.

My skin barrier is fickle; a redness-prone, easily aggravated beast.

These days, pairing a good occlusive with a hydrating powerhouse is a non-negotiable for me.

Dieux Skin Instant Angel moisturizer tube in hand

Emily McDonagh

Ahead, I put five potential Aquaphor alternatives to the plump-it-up test.

Here’s what I thought of each.

|Rating:8/10

Not just a solo slather, Futurewise is a game-changingslugging system.

Byrdie writer Emily McDonagh applies Dieux Skin’s Instant Angel moisturizer

Emily McDonagh

Post-cleanse, I apply the mist and moisturizer for a hydration boost, then seal it with the balm.

The balm is the real star of this show.

It’s a dreamy, lightweight, plant-based answer to all my greasy wake-ups.

Dieux Instant Angel moisturizer and box

This hero product is a great option for those new to slug life or prone to decision fatigue.

|Rating:8.5/10

This slugging duo is a power couple in the making.

Layering a hydrating serum, a lipid-rich moisturizer, and theCeraVeHealing Ointmentis heaven-sent.

CeraVe Healing Ointment tube

My resulting skin was particularly plumpthe kind of healthy, glowy look that invites Zoom compliments.

Made forpost-procedureskin, its heavy-duty nourishment is unlike anything I’ve applied before.

Despite the price, a little goes a long way.

iS Clinical Sheald Recovery Balm in shadowed environment

@isclinical

Still, this balm soothes and calms well beyond your Walgreens go-to, which my redness-prone skin needs weekly.

This top-shelf pick works hard beyond the occlusion and is a great option if deep nourishment is your priority.

|Rating:7/10

A skincare brand I can shop as part of my Whole Foods run?

Byrdie writer Emily McDonagh with radiant skin after applying the iS Clinical Sheald Recovery Balm

Emily McDonagh

Given the top-tier contenders, I would save the One-for-All Balm for desert-dry spots.

But TikTok has been raving about the La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5, so I had to test it.

The balm’s hero ingredient ispanthenol(a.k.a.

iS Clinical Sheald Recovery Balm

vitamin B5), a moisturizer that acts as both a humectant and an emollient.

Upon utility, I’m in slugging heaven: The texture isn’t tacky but slick.

For those who avoid silicones, this product has dimethicone.

Cocokind One-for-All Balm in hand in front of flowering bush

@cocokind

Here’s what stands out about a few of the favorites I tested above.

Byrdie writer Emily McDonagh’s skin after applying the Cocokind One-for-All Recovery Balm

Emily McDonagh

Cocokind One-for-All Balm

Embryolisse Lait-Crème Sensitive tube in hand

Emily McDonagh

Byrdie writer Emily McDonagh’s skin after applying Embryolisse and La Roche-Posay products

Emily McDonagh

Embryolisse Lait-Creme Sensitive

La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5