Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.

If you press links we provide, we may receive compensation.

These picks rival a set of falsies.

a collage of a tester trying fiber mascaras

Byrdie

These fibers tack on noticeable length and volume, mimicking the transformative effect offalsiesorlash extensions.

As youve probably noticed, many mascara formulas use fiber technology, making the shopping experience a little overwhelming.

I also evaluated the formulaswaterproof, water-resistant, flake-proof, and smudge-proof promises.

Glossier Lash Slick Lift and Lengthening Mascara

PHOTO: Glossier

Ahead are the fiber mascaras thatll convince you to cancel your lash extension appointment.

The narrow wand design also made it really easy to define my tiny lower lashes with the fiber-filled formula.

I was able to apply several layers without any clumping or flaking.

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using glossier lash stick

The fibers lengthen and add bulk to individual lashes, creating a full, fanned-out effect.

The wand features a cone-shaped brush that latches your lashes and distributes the smooth, lightweight pigment seamlessly.

Its also really easy to removeno harsh rubbing required.

Maybelline Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara

PHOTO: Amazon

The mascara wands brush picks up the perfect amount of product and glides through your lashes with ease.

This mascara makes my lashes look significantly thicker and adds noticeable length.

Out of all the mascaras I tested, this one had the most desirable volumizing effect.

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using maybelline illegal length fiber mascara

Though not completely waterproof, this mascara has a high-performance smudge-proof wear that can withstand asweaty workout.

My only major qualm was that I experienced some minor flaking by the end of the day.

Its also extremely effective at providing significant length to the upper lash line.

Milk Makeup Kush High Volume Mascara

PHOTO: Sephora

Thanks to the brushs small size, I was able to evenly coat my lashes from root to tip.

On top of noticeable definition and separation, the formula also provided a bold color payoff.

The mascara slipped right off my lashes when I removed it with bothmicellar waterand amakeup-removing balm.

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using milk makeup kush high volumizing mascara

Its definitelylengtheningand volumizing, but in my opinion, the formula provides a more natural look.

If I wanted a bold or more dramatic look, Id probably reach for another mascara.

That said, I never think waterproof mascaras perform as well as washable mascaras in that department.

Hourglass Cosmetics Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara

PHOTO: Sephora

The formula also held up through a very sweaty 6-mile run without any smearinga major win in my book.

I would recommend reaching for this MAC pick if length and definition are your top priorities.

Its lightweight, applied smoothly to my lashes, and didnt clump them together.

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using hourglass unlocked instant extensions mascara

I didnt have to do a ton of rubbing to cleanse my lashes.

Most fiber mascaras also provide a lifting effect.

Fiber mascara is considered safe, but fiber mascaras are prone to flaking.

Kevyn Aucoin The Volume Mascara

PHOTO: Amazon

First, ensure your eyelashes are clean to prevent clumping or a spidery appearance.

Place your mascara brush at the base of your lashes and slowly wiggle the brush from roots to tips.

Apply a few layers to fully coat your lashes or to create a more dramatic finish.

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using kevyn aucoin the volume mascara

Why Trust Byrdie

Victoria Moorhouseis a freelance beauty writer and a Byrdie contributor.

Victoria considers mascara to be the most important part of her extremely minimal makeup routine.

2020;17(18):6811. doi:10.3390/ijerph17186811

COVERGIRL Super Sizer Mascara

PHOTO: Walmart

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using Covergirl the super sizer waterproof mascara

MAC Cosmetics Magic Extension 5MM Fibre Mascara

PHOTO: MAC Cosmetics

Site Loop: Person’s face before and after using MAC magic extension 5mm fibre mascara

Glossier Lash Slick Mascara

Byrdie